Theodoras Family Restaurant and Pizza in Wharton

Have been here on a few occasions. Always busy servicing numerous orders. Good Pizza, salads and dinners.

George, Rose, Tony and the staff are great! Food is excellent, so is the service! !

Awesome neighborhood joint ..

Great food and descent service, but service went down as we were leaving the waitress was complaining about her tip loud enough that we heard it going out the door so I know rest of the people at lunch can hear it.

Fantastic food with a friendly atmosphere. They clearly take pride in quality and consistency. Very deserving of their high ratings. Two thumbs up!

Mothers Day. Im sure they were busy but was informed to pre-order so we preordered Saturday, my husband still waited 45min to get our food. Veal Saltimbocca had no prosciutto and was cold, side salad had hair in it and husband found plastic in calamari fra diavolo. Also ran out of veal for daughters veal parm sandwich so she got chicken parm even though preordered day before. Overal not very happy. Garlic knots were good, silver lining I guess.

Great food great service and great prices !!! 5 star

This is by far the gem of North Jersey. You want Greek(real Greek) food, Italian food or just great pizza, Theodoras is the place. Great service and the owner George is phenomenol. He called me at home to tell me he have fresh anchovies and of course I went there and he made them for my wife and I. Great man great business owner and AWESOME!!!! restaurant. 10 Stars. See you soon George! Magnificent meal.***********

I've only been once, but I like it so far! The sausage and lentil soup was excellent!

I love this place! The food is ALWAYS fresh with good portion sizes. The menu offers a wide variety & they will special order a dish for you if you ask. This restaurant really aims to please. By far one of the best restaurants around.

It is a good restaurant.I ordered gyro plates.There was not much meat on it.I thought it could be better with amount I paid.Price was around 15 dollars

Delicious. Great little gem

Nice family owned restaurant. Service is awesome. Food is delicious. Highly recommend it.

Wow such a plesant place . Our hostess was friendly and fast, and the food was great. I recommend this place to eat with your family.

A cozy restaurant in USA!!!Large portions. Tasty menu. Friendly service.

This place is amazing. I was new to the area and a friend told me they had great pizza. I had the best pizza experience in my life I go there at least once a week. Pasta vodka is phenomenal. The staff is so welcoming and friendly you feel like family. Their food is so off-the-chart amazing I just can't say anything else. You must go and experience this happy mouth full of joy when you order anything on their menu.

One of my preferred places to grab some food. fantastic location, clean, and excellent customer service. A must try!

We love coming here. The service is always so friendly and the food is absolutely amazing. I feel like sometimes I come for just the bread! My husband loves the Greek offerings and I usually stay with the basic Italian offerings, which are always so delicious. Normally I can make at least two meals from the leftovers, too!

Its my favorite! Close to home and great prices. The ladies nice and the man is rude! But overall good food.

This spot never fails to impress. They serve fantastic dishes for fair prices, there no long wait even when the spot is packed.

This business is overall very much recommended. Once you have a bite from whichever dish, you know the food is authentic. The simplest thing which is the bread is just outstanding and blew me away. The chicken is remarkably juicy and leaves you wanting more yet very much satisfied. Staff is very friendly and welcoming as well as accommodating for reservations. Truly and highly recommended!

Great gyro and sides, plus good coffee and pastries for dessert. Loved the staff and friendly atmosphere.

Visited from Colorado with my wife who's from the area. Some of the best Italian food I've ever had.

We had a group event here of twenty + people, and the staff was very accommodating. Eggplant Parmesan was delicious! BYOB.

Excellent!!! George, the owner is definitely a quality restauranteur. Quality of the food is King with him! We had the Lamb Special and it was very good. The Greek salad was good, the bread was good, the Greek dessert was good and our waitress: Christy was very sweet, friendly and very attentive.We will definitely come back to Theodora's Family Restaurant. Thank you, George for a very nice evening. Patrick and Jill Livingston, New Jersey.

Food is always excellent and reasonably priced. Only pickup currently available and it takes place on the front porch to insure the safety of all. Make sure you visit soon.

Excellent food. Excellent service. Excellent people. Highly recommend to anyone.

My family and I have eaten at this restaurant on multiple occasions. The food several years ago was good. Is it possible that the food has actually improved in flavor recently? Try the Italian dishes or the Greek favorites which are also excellent. The wait staff couldn’t be any more helpful. On top of a full meal each dinner is further embellished with a freshly made hot roll with butter. Bread never tasted so good. Cost effective, convenient and tasty. Your table is waiting!

tied for number one pizza in the area in my book. definitely great consistent quality.

Very friendly staff good food at a fair price range

Excellent food at reasonable prices!!

As I come in the Restaurant I was very impressed by the dinning area. My choice of Pizza was a pepperoni and bacon 🍕 and it was delicious. I really enjoy the environment and their pizza. Great place for family and friends. Staff are great!! Good work!

Absolutely delicious meal friendly atmosphere fantastic service highly recommend

a spectacular place to eat service and food the best, wonderful place to enjoy with family with the company of george and his team remember a family place if you do not like the noises of children and want to eat without finding a noise around you this is a family restaurant .10 stars for theodoras family restaurant!!

Super affordable, cozy, and DELICIOUS Greek cooking. The spanakopita dinner is huge and comes with a killer Greek salad. Baklava is also to die for. BYOB!

Great food and good service.😊👍

Awesome service great food !

Always fresh, always hot!

Fantastic food, fantastic people!! A+++

Good local joint. Good food & good size portions at a modest price. Friendly staff and owner eager to please. BYOB too!

Beat Greek food in Wharton NJ. Thank you for the experience and will be back soon again! Highly recommend if your in Wharton.

One of my favorite restaurants in the Morris County area. Good for kids and your family, and BYOB. We go a lot. My go to is the Chicken Francese. They have the best bread! Fresh out of the oven! I also love their Chicken Soup in the winter. One of the best chicken soups around! Friendly service & family owned.

Great food and friendly staff. Had the homemade lasagna which was very good. The "bread" served with the meal was actually a HUGE roll which was very tasty. The crabcakes were also good.

Food was wonderful, service also excellent even during the early New Year's Eve crowd.

Great food, great people, covid safe.

Excellent food always and waitress really kept that whole place going. Sorry forgot her name.

Outstanding spot for quality Pizza. Visited Fri evening I think. The service was very kind and attentive. The place has a nice atmosphere.

I love this place. I pass 2 maybe 3 other pizza places to get to Theodore's. The food is authentic. The sauce is delicious. The bread is to die for. And the service treats you like family. I walked in Super Bowl Sunday and the boss was laying on the couch watching the game. It made me feel like I walked into my own home and got a plate from the kitchen. I Love It!!!

Great food, great service and friendly people working here. No complaints whatsoever